In Focus: McGinn a potential star for Celtic but £5m is a stretch

Speaking to BT Sport this past weekend, Hibernian manager Neil Lennon has placed a hefty price tag on long-term Celtic target John McGinn.

What’s the story?

McGinn has emerged as one of the most exciting Scottish midfield talents in recent years, shining for Hibs and winning international caps for Gordon Strachan’s national side.

The Daily Express reported at the end of last month that Celtic and Ipswich Twon were interested in his signature, even suggesting that the Hoops see him as a long-term successor to club captain Scott Brown.

However if the Hoops want him, they’ll need to pay a pretty penny according to Hibs boss Neil Lennon.

Speaking candidly to BT Sport, Lennon said of his situation:

I can’t guarantee it but he’s not for sale. It’s going to take a huge bid from any club to take John away from us, £4-5 million. He’s still got a bit to do but already he is a quality player. He’s a Scottish international.

Does that put the 22-year-old out of Celtic’s price range or will they be tempted to secure his services?

Is he worth that kind of money?

There’s no doubting that McGinn possesses great ability for his age but he still has a lot to prove, even by Scottish football standards. While he’s really gained prominence at Hibs, he’s yet to feature for them in the top-flight, with the Edinburgh side only being promoted from the Championship last term.

While he did also perform well for St Mirren in the Scottish Premiership before his move to Easter Road, did he do enough to justify such a price tag?

Celtic fans will remember that the club also had to shell out big money for Scott Brown when he signed for the club ten years ago, so it’s not unprecedented for the Hoops to pay decent money when they feel they have a future star on their hands.

Another full season in the Scottish top-flight with Hibs, now he’s had a few years more development since his time in Paisley, will go a long way to determining his true potential.

However, the Hoops shouldn’t sleep on signing him if they sense they could be beaten to his signature by a team in England.

The Strike: Javier Hernandez shows the value of the throwback poacher

Javier Hernandez is a footballer without many peers in the modern game.

A Central American star plying his trade in Europe, he is one of the few to make it at the likes of Real Madrid and Manchester United, playing in some of the biggest games in European club football. That’s perhaps why he’s revered in his home land, and perhaps why he has nearly eight times as many followers on Twitter as his new club, West Ham United. He is a hero.

But that modern portrait of a superstar footballer is only part of the image Hernandez beams to the world. In many ways, he’s a player out of time.

He is not a full-throttle attacker who hassles and harries defenders into making a mistake, and so not a player you’d expect Jurgen Klopp or Pep Guardiola to be enamoured with. Nor is he a beastly specimen of a player, one Jose Mourinho might be interested in. In terms of stature and even style of play, you get the feeling that Hernandez would have looked more natural in the little-and-large days of two-men strike forces.

Even his name is out of time. Nicknames are not a phenomenon modern football seems to have a lot of time for. These days, referring to Lionel Messi as ‘The Flea’ or to David Beckham as ‘Golden Balls’ – something that feels retro even now – seems hopelessly naff. At the very best, it’s used as a sarcastic reference. Javier ‘Chicharito’ Hernandez, The Little Pea, is an exception to the rule. Indeed, it’s not just a nickname in some ways – referring to him as Chicharito rather than Hernandez is pretty much an unquestioned done thing, or at least an equally popular way of referring to him. It’s a tragedy football has lost nicknames like that.

But somehow, the Mexican seems to make it all work with a modern twist. He is unique, and yet he pulls parts of football’s glorious past and marries them with its glittery present. When you think about it, it’s stunning that millions of social media users follow a man with a nickname that could have been given to a 1970s poacher. Indeed, when you think about it, Chicharito could well have passed for a 1970s poacher on the pitch, too.

In some ways, Hernandez has only two parts to his game: movement and goals. And the second is only possible because of the first. As players like that become rarer and rarer, perhaps that’s why Hernandez should be thought of as more and more valuable. And it’s why West Ham may well have pulled off the deal of the summer in nabbing him from Bayer Leverkusen, taking a Champions League quality striker whilst Champions League teams buy attackers for double and triple the price.

And it might just be Hernandez’s Champions League highlight – maybe his defining moment – which shows just how such a throwback of a player is so valuable in the modern game.

In 2015, when Real Madrid were partnered with their city rivals Atletico – as they have been for each of the last four years – it was Chicharito who broke the fabled Diego Simeone defence down. And he didn’t do it with style or or verve, he did it with movement. Or, more accurately, he did it with a distinct lack of it. Because sometimes you only need to stand still to make the greatest impact.

The first leg at the Calderon had finished 0-0, and the second leg in the Bernabeu looked set to end the same way, even after Arda Turan was sent off for a second bookable offence with just 15 minutes left to play. By the time Cristiano Ronaldo cut in from the right hand-side, and played a one-two with a teammate before bursting into the box, there were only two minutes left on the clock.

Real were the reigning champions, having beaten Atletico after extra time in the final the previous year. But such is the celebrity and the power of Ronaldo that, even in a game of that magnitude, all eyes were drawn to the Portuguese legend as he attempted to take his team by the scruff of the neck and drag them into another Champions League semi-final.

But those eyes were in the wrong place. And, most importantly, so were those of Jose Maria Gimenez. The youngster had been on the pitch just three minutes, after coming on to replace Tiago in an attempt to see out the 90 minutes and get to extra time. You could forgive a bit of ball-watching in such a situation, but this proved to be vital.

As Ronaldo burst into the box, Gimenez drifted to defend the Portuguese’s run, but the man was supposed to be marking – Hernandez – barely moved at all, taking just one step backwards onto the penalty spot, finding himself in just enough space to alert Ronaldo to the possibility of squaring the ball rather than shooting himself.

Ronaldo, slipping, falling, and facing the wrong direction had no alternative, and poked the ball into Chicharito’s path, and the Mexican – himself falling backwards – cooly slotted the ball between the despairing lunges of both the goalkeeper and defender beside him.

It’s arguably the most important goal of the Mexican’s career, to knock one of the tournament’s best sides out of the competition at the quarter final stage and taking Real Madrid into another Champions League semi with a goal in the final minutes of the game.

It was also a trademark Hernandez goal. A poacher’s goal, but one made through sheer understanding of how to find space in the penalty area. It’s a handy knack for a striker. It means finishing doesn’t need to be a special quality because it makes the finishes easier.

For a club like West Ham, whose only prolific striker in recent memory is the hopelessly injured Andy Carroll, to sign Hernandez might just be the deal of the summer.

Three things Celtic can offer Patrick Roberts that no other club can

It’s the transfer rumour that won’t go away this summer. A saga that has rumbled on since before last season even ended. In his time on loan at Celtic, Patrick Roberts became a massive fan favourite and supporters couldn’t bear the thought of him returning to Manchester City.

Since he left to join up with Pep Guardiola’s squad, fans have discussed to death the prospect of him returning to Glasgow.

This week that speculation has reached fever pitch after outlets like the BBC reporting that he was due to tell Man City that he wants to return to the Hoops next season. With the BBC also reporting that teams like Ligue 1 side Nice are also interested in his signature, competition is fierce for the young winger after his excellent performances last season.

However, Celtic can offer him more than most other clubs in Europe who are at his level right now and here are THREE big reasons why he should choose the Hoops over anyone else…

A devoted fanbase

Even if Patrick Roberts never plays for Celtic again, he’s unlikely to find a club whose supporters will love him as much as Celtic fans do. The Hoops fans are notoriously passionate and adoring, but the relationship with Patrick Roberts was a new level, with his dynamic trickery, pace and excellent finishing ability appreciated by a support who love attacking football.

They recognise his potential to become an elite player and believe that he can achieve that with Celtic. It’s the kind of backing that most players would be lucky to have.

If he signed for Celtic tomorrow the response would be massive and give him the platform to achieve massive things with the club should he continue to develop at the same rate he has done over the last 18 months.

Somewhere new and he’ll have to work hard to fit in all over again.

First team Champions League football

If Patrick Roberts moved to Celtic, the club have one massive attraction, UEFA Champions League football. It’s the pinnacle of a player’s club career and having already had a taste at such a young age, we expect that Roberts has ambitions to play in the group stages of competition many more times.

Sure, Manchester City will be there too but he isn’t going to get the game time or be trusted enough by Pep Guardiola to be starting there quite yet. At Celtic he is all but guaranteed of at least competing for places.

The Hoops are well placed to go through the play-off round vs Astana and are looking to improve on their fourth placed finish in the groups last term. Patrick Roberts was pivotal in some European matches last season including scoring a headline-grabbing goal against his parent club Manchester City and providing the assist for Leigh Griffiths in Kazakhstant to help them progress in qualifying.

He can make his name on this stage once again and a move to another Premier League club may not build his profile in the same way.

Brendan Rodgers

Another aspect unique to Celtic is Brendan Rodgers, one of the best man managers in Britain and one of the best head coaches anywhere when it comes to developing young talent. From his days in the backroom staff at Chelsea right through to his current role at Celtic, he’s always prided himself on working with young players.

The main beneficiaries of that at the Hoops right now are Kieran Tierney and Moussa Dembele, two players who have seen their stock and standing in the game rise massively under the former Liverpool manager.

Another season working with Rodgers could be massive Roberts career in the long-term, enhancing his game with the small details the Celtic coaching staff can pass on and getting the regular week-to-week football in an attacking, possession-based team that can provide the mentality for him to be a success at elite clubs.

HYS: Liverpool fans, who is your signing of the summer?

The Premier League obliterated its spending records once again this summer, the transfer window just gone witnessing a staggering £1.4billion outlay on new arrivals.

In comparison to the rest of the top six, Liverpool’s spending was on the modest side, shelling out around £80million on Mohamed Salah, Andrew Robertson, Alex Oxlade-Chamberlain and Dominic Solanke.

But the Egypt international is already proving himself to be a real asset for the Reds, bagging two goals and one assist in three Premier League appearances and adding even more pace on the break to Jurgen Klopp’s side.

However, is the 25-year-old the Premier League’s signing of the summer, or will another top flight star earn himself that title come the end of the campaign?

Keen to hear the fans’ opinions on the Premier League’s best piece of business during the transfer window, we’ve drawn up a list of 35 candidates. So, Liverpool fans, who is your signing of the summer? Let us know by voting below…

Southampton fans slam Nathan Redmond after Crystal Palace win

Southampton bounced back from the disappointing defeat to Watford last weekend when they beat Crystal Palace 1-0 at Selhurst Park on Saturday, but Saints fans were not impressed with Nathan Redmond’s performance.

Mauricio Pellegrino knew that his side needed to show a reaction from the 2-0 loss against the Hornets last time out, and his side got off to the perfect start when Steven Davis scored what proved to be the decisive goal in the sixth minute.

Redmond once again started on the left-hand side for the visitors but he struggled to have an impact in south London, instead being reduced to a few weak shots from outside the penalty area.

Southampton supporters were quick to have their say on the showing of the 23-year-old winger via social media, and they were less than pleased.

While some said that he “needs to be dropped”, others described his performance as a “complete embarrassment”.

Here is just a selection of the Twitter reaction…

Oxlade-Chamberlain struggles to justify price-tag with abysmal England performance

There were few players who could hold their heads up high last night after England’s shambolic snooze-fest with Slovenia, a match containing such limited action even Joe Hart’s double-save that proved to be insignificant as the linesman raised his offside flag managed to make the highlight reel.

Indeed, Harry Kane’s last-minute toe-poke acquired the points England needed to guarantee their place at the 2018 World Cup but judging by their performance against a side currently 55th in the FIFA rankings, the Three Lions will need to make drastic improvements if they intend to give a strong account of themselves in Russia next summer.

Even so, one abysmal individual performance particularly stood out, coming from Liverpool’s summer signing Alex Oxlade-Chamberlain – who Transfermarkt value at £19.8million. The Reds forked out almost double that sum to sign the versatile midfielder from Arsenal during the summer and it’s already looking like money poorly spent.

In addition to making marginal impact during his five substitute appearances for Liverpool thus far, the 24-year-old suffered a particularly poor night against Slovenia. Despite being one of England’s most advanced players in the right wing role, Oxlade-Chamberlain didn’t create a single chance, complete a single cross or have an effort at goal – while his passing accuracy was just 62%.

When Gareth Southgate hauled off the 30-cap international just after the hour mark, Arsenal fans must have been struggling to contain their laughter – and Liverpool fans must have been left wondering why their club spent so much money and effort bringing him to Anfield on Deadline Day.

Revealed: Arsenal fans vote Monreal MOTM from win over West Brom

It’s not often we praise Arsenal for their efforts at the back but after a 2-0 win over West Bromwich Albion on Monday night, the Gunners are now amid a run of four clean sheets from their last five games across all competitions – the only exception being a stunning goal from FC Koln’s Jhon Cordoba.

That’s some reaction to the 4-0 humiliation at the hands of Liverpool before the international break and as the Baggies peppered Arsenal’s goal with sweeping counter-attacks in the first half, it was once again their defensive resilience that stood out – most notably a goal-line clearance from Nacho Monreal.

Perhaps unsurprisingly then, when we asked Arsenal fans to vote for their Man of the Match from the 2-0 win, it wasn’t brace-bagger Alexande Lacazette who won our poll – rather the 31-year-old defender who occupied the left-hand slot in the Gunners’ back three.

The 53% share of the vote is more than justified; the Spaniard, who Transfermarkt value at £11.7million, was a real rock at the back and missed just 6% of his passes against West Brom, as shown above.

Arsenal fans react as Mesut Ozil closes in on new contract with the club

That’s right Arsenal fans. Don’t pinch yourselves, it has finally happened. After what seems like an age, Mesut Ozil, or more accurately his agent, has confirmed that a new Arsenal contract is being worked on.

Speaking to the Turkish media earlier this week, Ozil’s agent Dr Erkut Sogut stated;

“Ozil wants to play another two to three years in the Premier League. Our contacts with Arsenal continue and are going in a positive way.”

Whether they want Ozil to remain at the club or not, Arsenal fans will be undoubtedly happy to hear the news that this saga is coming to a conclusion. Along with Alexis Sanchez, Mesut Ozil’s contract situation has been hanging over the Emirates for over a year, like an unwanted dark cloud.

While the German international, who is valued at £45million by Transfermarket, close to resolving his Arsenal future, Gunners fans took to Twitter to share their thoughts…and its safe to say that they weren’t impressed…

Revealed: Majority of Liverpool fans want Oxlade-Chamberlain to start vs Tottenham

Alex Oxlade-Chamberlain’s been forced to wait for his chances since moving to Liverpool in the summer. In fact, the 30-cap England international is yet to make his first Premier League start for Jurgen Klopp’s side after arriving from Arsenal in a Deadline Day deal.

[ad_pod id=’leo-vegas’]

But after scoring his first goal for Liverpool in midweek as the Reds cruised to a 7-0 demolition of Maribor in the Champions League, the timing feels right to bring Oxlade-Chamberlain into the starting XI – especially considering the Reds face the former Arsenal man’s old rivals Tottenham in the Premier League on Sunday.

With that in mind, we asked Liverpool fans earlier this week whether the 24-year-old should make his first top flight start for the club this weekend and according to our poll, 52% of Reds supporters think he should.

But that inevitably begs the question of where Oxlade-Chamberlain actually fits into this Liverpool side. Where would you start him on Sunday? Let us know by commenting below…

Sunderland beware: The gap between the rich and the poor is growing in the Championhsip

Sunderland are in freefall. No one thought it would be easy for the recently relegated club to bouce straight back to the Premier League after a season in the Championship, not with a squad like theirs and the scant resources they appear to have, but their struggles are profound.

Now managerless and in the relegation zone, the Black Cats are apparently in dire straits. Billy McKinlay – who was only promoted to first-team coach because of an illness to Simon Grayson’s assistant Glynn Snodin – and Robbie Stockdale – who started his career at Middlesbrough – will take the reins jointly this weekend, but it doesn’t look good for the club who seemed to make an art of Premier League survival thanks to sacking managers at the right time.

You get the feeling that the dead Black Cat bounce will need to work in the Championship this time around, too. Already in the bottom three, Birmingham up ahead are only two points ahead. But above that, there’s a five point gap back to Sunderland. Put another way, it’s still early days, and while there’s no such thing as a relegation battle just yet – given there are so many games to go – they need to pick up wins quickly.

The fact that there seems to be no ‘real’ danger is also one of the reasons that Sunderland should be very worried indeed: it’s a false sense of security if you don’t actually pick up points in the near future. You only have to look at clubs like Blackburn currently, or indeed the Sheffield clubs, Norwich City or even Manchester City in the late 90s to see just how easy it is for traditionally big clubs to drop into the third tier.

The problem now is who the new manager might be.

That’s the difference between this weekend’s opponents, Middlesbrough, and Sunderland. When the Black Cats were relegated, there was still talk of David Moyes staying on in the dugout. When he was sacked, the appointment of Grayson was only completed after the current owners were unable to sell the club. Such indecisiveness seems to have cost the club. Boro, on the other hand, made a very quick decision to appoint Garry Monk, a man who took Leeds within a game of the play-offs last season, despite their own previous chairman’s peccadilloes.

His start at the North Yorkshire side wasn’t the best, but after getting to know the club and the players, it seems as though Middlesbrough are starting to motor. Bringing in Monk meant a new manager with new ideas coming into a club which was low after relegation. By now, a few months later, Boro are only nine points off top spot, and things change quickly in the Championship.

[ad_pod ]

Indeed, from ninth place to fifth place, the table is starting to look fairly ominous. Clubs like Middlesbrough, Norwich City, Aston Villa and Leeds United – grand old English clubs with Premier League pedigree – are sitting menacingly just behind the likes of Cardiff City and Sheffield United, the early pace-setters.

It shows the benefit of decisiveness and spending money in the summer. But perhaps mostly the money part.

We’ve been warned quite a bit recently that the Premier League’s TV rights deal, which has seen £8bn flood into the league, would have an effect on the Championship. Parachute payments from a league that is pulling even further away from the one below will only populate the top of the second tier with the same clubs year in and year out, with the only difference being the teams that come down replace the three who go up.

Sunderland are showing that isn’t the case, but as Middlesbrough and the other around them start to gain results, it shows that size matters in the Championship. And despite the fact that this is still a league where ‘anyone can beat anyone’ the bigger clubs will rise to the top in the end.

This weekend is the sort of game that Sunderland will need to start winning relatively soon, then, if they’re to stick with the pace of the biggest clubs in the division and not sink towards the bottom, where the smaller clubs congregate these days. Things will only get more pronounced on that front.

Game
Register
Service
Bonus